There are no key terms for this page.

Qualified Plans and Individual Retirement Accounts

In Chapter 2, The Federal Income Tax Return, we learned about the taxability of income from retirement plans. In this chapter, we will discuss the deductions and other tax savings that are available by saving for retirement.

Retirement plans are often described as defined benefit or defined contribution plansdefined contribution planRetirement plan where the amount being contributed into the plan is known, but the benefits depend on the plan earnings over time.. A defined benefit plandefined benefit planRetirement plan where the benefit that the recipient will receive can be computed using the factors of age, number of years working, and income level. provides the recipient a set amount of income that is computed based on the recipient’s age, number of years worked, and income level. An employee can look at those factors in advance and determine the amount of retirement income that will be received. A defined contribution plan does not have that certainty. Instead, the amount that is being contributed by the employer and/or employee is known, but the amount that will be received at retirement depends on the amount contributed and earned over the years.

Qualified retirement plans are available through employers. Tax law provides taxpayers and their employers with an incentive to plan for retirement. Under the tax law, favorable tax treatment is given to contributions, by or for employees, to qualified retirement plans. Employers may claim a deduction in the current year for contributions to qualified retirement plans on the employees’ behalf, while the employees do not include the employer contributions in income until the contributed amounts are distributed. Earnings on the amounts contributed to the plan are also deferred. This deferral of income taxation is a significant benefit to most taxpayers.

Taxpayers contributing to a qualified plan through their employer will not have an adjustment on their income tax return. Instead, on the W-2 the employer furnishes, the amount contributed by the employee will have been deducted from the amount of income that is reported as taxable.

There are many kinds of qualified retirement plans including pension plans, profit-sharing plans, stock bonus plans, employee stock ownership plans, and Section 401(k) plans. A 401(k)401(k)Type of tax advantaged retirement plan. plan often permits the employee to receive compensation in cash or to defer part of the income and invest it in a structured plan. The maximum percentage an employee can defer is 15% or a maximum of $15,500 ($20,500 for an employee 50 or older) and the amounts are reduced if the employee participates in other tax sheltered plans.

Individual retirement accounts (IRAs) often result in a tax deduction. Taxpayers do have the opportunity to invest in other retirement vehicles like IRAs, which can result in a tax deduction. There are three types of IRAs but only one is deductible. The three types are:

  1. A traditional or regular IRA, which is deductible.

  2. A traditional or regular IRA with nondeductible deposits.

  3. A Roth IRA, which is not deductible.

It is important to understand that IRAs are savings plans through which funds are invested—IRAs are not a specific investment. An IRA can be placed in a certificate of deposit with a bank, in an account with a mutual fund company, which then invests in equity or bond investments of corporations, or they can be deposited with a brokerage firm and directly invested in stocks and bonds and other financial instruments. The IRA, when established, will be designated as a “traditional” or “Roth” IRA.

From a financial planning perspective, IRAs are one of the best vehicles for individuals to save money for retirement and can often be used to save taxes. No matter which IRA is used, the earnings on the account are tax free until withdrawn. A traditional IRA provides an immediate tax deduction as a deduction for AGI and funds, when withdrawn, are taxable. Deposits to a Roth IRA do not create an immediate deduction, but all withdrawals at retirement are tax free.

Each type of IRA has limitations in the amounts that can be deposited. Tables 17-1, 17-2 and 17-3 in Publication 17 provide information on the phaseout of the IRA deduction based on a modified adjusted gross income, whether the taxpayer is in another retirement program with an employer, and age. The amount of the deduction is calculated using the IRA Deduction Worksheet included in the 1040 instructions. Another way to compute the amount of the deduction is to use the following formula:

IRA allowable deduction=highest amount of modified AGI  in phaseout  taxpayer's actual modified AGI/dollar range in phase out

For a traditional IRA, the maximum deductible contribution is $5,000 or $6,000 if age 50 or older.

Go to Publication 17 and read chapter 17: Individual Retirement Arrangements.

Questions and Problems

  1. Brie has a Roth IRA held more than five years to which she has contributed $20,000. The IRA has a current value of $50,000. Brie is 55 years old and she takes a distribution of $38,000. How much of the distribution will be taxable?

    1. $0

    2. $18,000

    3. $30,000

    4. $38,000

    5. Some other amount

  2. Brienna has a Roth IRA held more than five years to which she has contributed $50,000. The IRA has a current value of $84,000. Brienna is 65 years old and she takes a distribution of $24,000. How much of the distribution will be taxable?

    1. $0

    2. $8,000

    3. $30,000

    4. $38,000

    5. Some other amount

  3. Carrie has a Roth IRA held longer than five years to which she has contributed $40,000. The IRA has a current value of $84,000. Carrie is 55 years old and she takes a distribution of $32,000 after retiring on disability. How much of the distribution will be taxable?

    1. $0

    2. $8,000

    3. $30,000

    4. $38,000

    5. Some other amount

  4. What is the maximum number of distribution rollovers a taxpayer can make during one tax year for an IRA?

    1. One

    2. Two

    3. Four

    4. Ten

    5. There is no limit

  5. Gerda and Hans are 29-year-old newlyweds and file a joint tax return. Gerda is covered by a retirement plan at work, but Hans is not.

    1. Assuming Hans’s wages were $28,000 and Gerda’s wages were $38,000 for 2008 and they had no other income, what is the maximum amount of their deductible contributions to an IRA?

      Gerda $__________ Hans $__________

    2. Assuming Hans’s wages were $45,000 and Gerda’s wages were $59,000 for 2008 and they had no other income, what is the maximum amount of their deductible contributions to an IRA?

      Gerda $__________ Hans $__________

  6. Irene, age 32, has a $120,000 IRA with Carter Mutual Fund. She has read good things about the management of Cleveland Mutual Fund, so she opens a Cleveland Fund IRA. Irene receives her balance from the Carter Fund on May 1, 2008.

    1. What amount will Irene receive from the Carter Fund IRA? $__________

    2. What amount must Irene contribute to the Cleveland Fund IRA to avoid having taxable income and penalties for early withdrawal? $__________

    3. When is the last day Irene can rollover the amount received into the Cleveland Fund IRA and avoid taxation in the current year, assuming no unusual circumstances? __________

    4. What amount would Irene receive if the distribution were from her employer’s qualified retirement plan? $__________

Creative Commons License Information

Cite this Content